Philosopher · Antiquity
Mozi (Mo Di)
c. 470–391 BC · Mohism; founder
Founder of Mohism, the chief rival of Confucianism before the Qin; Christian readers in China from the Jesuits to the twentieth century have compared impartial care with charity, and Nostra Aetate 2 commends what is true and holy in the Chinese traditions.
Mo Di, a craftsman or military engineer of humble origin, founded a disciplined order whose ten doctrines are preserved in the Mozi: impartial care (jian ai) for all persons without regard to family or state, since partiality is the source of every harm; condemnation of offensive war as the greatest of crimes, while his followers made themselves experts in the defense of besieged cities; moderation in expenditure and in funerals, and rejection of music, as useless costs; the will of Heaven, which loves all impartially and rewards and punishes, as the “compass and square” of righteousness; the existence of ghosts and spirits, argued from the testimony of many; rejection of fate; promotion of the worthy; and “conformity upward,” so that the judgments of the whole state agree with the ruler and the ruler with Heaven. Every doctrine is tested by three standards: the precedent of the sage kings, the evidence of the people's eyes and ears, and its benefit to the state and people in wealth, population and order.
Why he matters: He is the first consequentialist in history and the first Chinese thinker to argue for a personal, loving, judging Heaven, and Christian missionaries and modern Chinese Christians alike saw in impartial care a foreshadowing of universal charity; his twentieth-century revival was partly driven by that comparison. He is also the standing case against Confucian graded love, which is why Mencius attacked him by name.
Where to be careful
His ethic measures acts by benefit to state and people, so that no act is wrong in itself, music and mourning are waste, and the person is worth what he contributes, against the Church's teaching on intrinsically evil acts (Veritatis Splendor 71–83) and on the dignity of the person; his Heaven is a judge, not a Creator or a Father. His impartial love, his condemnation of aggressive war, his Heaven that sees all and loves all, and his concern for the poor and the many are a true preparation for the Gospel.
Reading
-
Mozi: Basic WritingsMozi (trans. Burton Watson) · The core doctrinal chapters, including impartial care, the will of Heaven and against offensive war.
-
The Mozi: A Complete TranslationMozi (trans. Ian Johnston) · The whole text with the Chinese, for the dialectical and military chapters.
-
Chinese ReligionsJulia Ching · A Catholic sinologist's survey that places Mozi's personal Heaven and impartial care beside Confucian and Christian alternatives.
Documented positions
Where this thinker stands on each dispute the test covers.