All thinkers

Philosopher · Contemporary

Bertrand Russell

1872–1970 · Logical atomism; analytic empiricism

Outside the Church Secular (agnostic); aristocratic Whig upbringing

A lifelong unbeliever who debated the existence of God with Fr. Frederick Copleston on the BBC in 1948 and lost a New York professorship in 1940 over his views on marriage.

Russell, with Whitehead, tried in Principia Mathematica (1910–1913) to derive mathematics from logic, and his theory of descriptions and logical atomism made him a founder of analytic philosophy. The Problems of Philosophy (1912) defended a realism about universals and a correspondence theory of truth against pragmatism; in religion he was an agnostic who found every proof of God wanting, called the doctrine of hell cruel, and in “A Free Man's Worship” (1903) built a stoic ethic on the ruins of a purposeless cosmos. He went to prison as a pacifist in 1918, supported the war against Hitler, led the campaign against nuclear weapons, and wrote Marriage and Morals (1929), A History of Western Philosophy (1945) and the Nobel-winning essays that made him the century's best-known skeptic.

Why he matters: The Russell–Copleston debate is still the clearest short exchange between the Thomist arguments and analytic doubt, and Copleston's History of Philosophy was written partly to correct Russell's. “Why I Am Not a Christian” set the terms of popular unbelief for two generations, and the questions it presses (the first cause, the moral argument, hell, the character of Christ) are exactly those apologetics has to answer.

Where to be careful

He denied that reason can reach God (Dei Filius ch. 2), the spiritual soul (Lateran V), free will (Trent Session 6 canon 5) and objective moral law, holding ethical judgments to be expressions of desire; his sexual ethics are contrary to Casti Connubii. What remains is a fierce respect for truth, logic and intellectual honesty, and a hatred of cruelty that the Church shares.

Reading

  • Why I Am Not a Christian
    Bertrand Russell · The 1927 lecture and the essays around it, including the Copleston debate.
  • The Problems of Philosophy
    Bertrand Russell · Short and lucid; his realism about universals and truth.
  • A History of Philosophy, Volume 8: Bentham to Russell
    Frederick Copleston · The Jesuit who debated him gives his philosophy a fair and critical hearing.

Documented positions

Where this thinker stands on each dispute the test covers.

Settled teaching Its center Open question Beyond teaching, not condemned Condemned error
I

God and Being · What is, and whence it is.

Can reason know that God exists? Fideism or agnosticism
Fideism or agnosticism Natural theology
How is God related to the world? Pantheism or emanation
Pantheism or emanation Creation from nothing
Is the world governed by purpose? Chance and mechanism
Chance and mechanism Providence and final causes
Do natures and essences really exist? Realism
Nominalism Realism
How does creation speak of God? Natures studied in their own right
Natures studied in their own right A book of signs and vestiges
II

Faith, Reason and Truth · How we know, and whom we trust.

Faith and reason: who has the last word? Rationalism
Rationalism Fideism
Where does knowledge begin? Senses and abstraction
Senses and abstraction Illumination and innate ideas
Is truth objective? Objective truth
Relativism and pragmatism Objective truth
Who interprets revelation? Private judgment
Private judgment Living Tradition and Magisterium
How should Scripture be read? Critical reductionism
Critical reductionism Fundamentalist literalism
Are the world's learning and arts a danger or a gift? A gift to be baptized
A danger: Athens has nothing to do with Jerusalem A gift to be baptized
III

The Human Person · Soul, body, freedom and the Fall.

Is there a spiritual soul? Mind is brain
Mind is brain Immortal spiritual soul
Is the body really you? Body–soul unity
Dualism Body–soul unity
Are you free? Determinism
Determinism Free will
How fallen is human nature? Basically good
Totally depraved Basically good
The body and its desires Desire as its own law
Contempt for the flesh Desire as its own law
Person and community Individualism
Individualism Collectivism
Marriage, sex and the body's meaning Defined by consent and identity
Given by nature and grace Defined by consent and identity
What is suffering for? An evil to be relieved
An evil to be relieved A share in the Cross
IV

The Moral Life · Law, virtue, conscience and the good.

Is morality objective and knowable? Relativism
Relativism Natural law
Why is the good good? Eternal law (intellectualism)
Divine command (voluntarism) Eternal law (intellectualism)
Are some acts always wrong? Consequentialism
Consequentialism Intrinsically evil acts
Rules or character? Morality of obligation
Morality of obligation Morality of virtue and beatitude
What is conscience? Autonomous conscience
Autonomous conscience Conscience bound to truth
What is happiness? Earthly flourishing
Earthly flourishing Beatitude in God
V

Grace and Salvation · How God saves, and whom.

Hell and hope All will be saved
The many are lost All will be saved
Where does your eye rest in Christ: His divinity or His humanity? The man Jesus of Nazareth
The eternal Word made flesh The man Jesus of Nazareth
VI

Church and Society · Authority, the state, wealth and the nation.

Church and state Laicism
Laicism Social kingship of Christ
The economic order Socialism
Socialism Laissez-faire capitalism
Where does authority come from? Social contract
Social contract Authority from God
Reform or tradition? Remake by reason
Remake by reason Guided by tradition
The nation and the Church Nation does not matter
Nation or race first Nation does not matter
May the state restrain false religion? Civil liberty for every religion
The confessional state: error has no rights Civil liberty for every religion
Which form of government best suits a Christian people? Democracy and participation
Monarchy and hierarchy Democracy and participation
May a Christian take up the sword? Never: the way of the Cross is nonviolence
Never: the way of the Cross is nonviolence Yes: war can be just and sometimes a duty
VII

Worship, Prayer and the Two Lungs · Liturgy, icons, the Spirit, and the See of Peter.

Holy Orders and the Church's constitution Reformable by the people
A clerical Church Reformable by the people
Contemplation or action? Action: the apostolate and the works of mercy
Action: the apostolate and the works of mercy Contemplation: the one thing needful

A profile of your philosophical and theological leanings, measured against the settled teaching of the Catholic Church, East and West. It is a tool for examination and reading, not an instrument of judgment.

Ad maiorem Dei gloriam.